• In addition, Mirantis has a well-documented open-source framework for creating your own plugins for a truly pure-play, open source, customized experience to meet each use cases’ requirements. OpenStack is used as a single point cloud-based platform. I suspect the results might be slightly different! The Dell EMC Ready Architecture for Red Hat OpenStack Platform simplifies and accelerates deployment. Red Hat OpenStack Platform A leading open source cloud infrastructure project—stabilized for your enterprise. Mirantis has its own version of OpenStack that competes with Red Hat, and is a technology partner with VMware on OpenStack installations. OpenStack's main competitors include Red Hat OpenShift, Virtustream, Red Hat, Mirantis and Vmware. Mirantis declared a major victory when automaker VW chose it over Red Hat for a huge OpenStack implementation, says a report from TechCrunch. Mirantis offers training and certification in both pure-play (vendor agnostic) open-source OpenStack and the Mirantis distribution. The Red Hat approach is to use their CloudForms project as an app catalog. The higher number of user-error issues are to be expected when dealing with a large set of manual CLI, context, and syntax related commands. Mirantis insists that partners revalidate their products with each major release (six-month cadence). Mirantis has a wide array of published partners across the technology silos offering pure-play options for end users in every aspect of their solution. Mirantis’ ‘Unlocked’ program provides transparent procedures, templates, scripts and tools for validating hardware; OpenStack drivers and infrastructure-level solutions; and application-level and/or OpenStack API-integrated solutions. Training, certification, and professional services are available worldwide. Mirantis this week rolled out Mirantis OpenStack for Kubernetes, an instance of the open source cloud management framework in which all the components Friday, December 11, 2020 Mirantis Melds Kubernetes With OpenStack They also incorporate many community-approved open-source technology options (e.g., Ceph) in their regular distributions, in robust reference configurations, configured and deployed automatically with Fuel. The Mirantis-initiated Murano orchestrator/app catalog and the Fuel deployer are both official OpenStack projects. While Mirantis has an advantage in overall bug fixes with 922 to Red Hat’s 794. Red Hat also scores reasonably well here. “Many of our larger customers run two or three different Linux flavors. Please enable Cookies and reload the page. However, the many errors in the documentation were unexpected. Hey, and thanks for a great read. From start to finish, the preponderance of steps are pure CLI commands with a heavy dependence on the documentation. Mirantis also develops all their code, bug fixes, etc. Mirantis’ roots are in professional services and training. On the other hand, the top reviewer of Ubuntu Linux writes "A stable, user-friendly solution that has good standardization, visualization, and package management". Red Hat OpenStack Platform A leading open source cloud infrastructure project—stabilized for your enterprise. Personally I’d suggest SUSE OpenStack … Mirantis OpenStack managed services are expensive. But, as a testament to Fuel’s network verification check, I was able to quickly diagnose and fix the issue. With basically equivalent pros and cons for both distros, the packaging comparison results in a draw. However, the deployment of the plugins is completely manual; CLI commands are required on each node that the plugin affects, which can be an administrative nightmare in large-scale deployments. Ironic registration of nodes requires some manual data collection that, especially at scale, can be troublesome. More OpenStack projects could be included. Mirantis Cloud Platform is rated 0.0, while Platform9 Managed OpenStack is rated 0.0. All Mirantis projects are developed 100% through a meritocracy-based community approach. Upgrade – Full upgrades continue to be challenging, but Mirantis does have a slight advantage with the inclusion of their Octane tooling for Fuel. We’ll pass that on for the next comparison we do. For the software comparison we are looking at the OpenStack distributions and not the host OS, hypervisor, or guest OS. For example, Red Hat has an advantage in the number of overall commits performed with over 5,200 to Mirantis’ over 3,400. Given that the validation testing section is held from the score, in terms of other factors, neither distro beats the other one on packaging. OpenStack update vs OpenStack upgrade¶. These may or may not be functional with each specific OSP release. So Mirantis Cloud-Native Platform addresses this whole continuum of needs, with maximum choice, simplicity, and security. Mirantis And Canonical Take A Swipe At Red Hat, Supporting Ubuntu On Top Of Mirantis OpenStack Ben Kepes Former Contributor Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Currently, there are hundreds of individual CLI commands required to achieve an upgrade; they have not yet provided any automation in scripting. Our experience with these errors resulted in many showstoppers, such as failed installations and deployments with cryptic logs. Red Hat Security specialist Keith Basil outlines the security roadmap strategy and vision for Red Hat OpenStack Platform. Outside of core projects, but still included in the distro, Red Hat leads on Ironic and have several projects included in their technology preview, like Designate and Trove. The main purpose of update is to provide minor updates for the OpenStack packages without changing the major versions of … Reference implementations are utilized, such as Logical Volume Manager (LVM) for Block Storage, Open vSwitch (OVS) for L2 networking, or KVM/QEMU for the hypervisor. Most companies build it to enable workloads like developer productivity tools, big data, NFV, etc. I am trying to understand what is the difference between OpenStack and CloudForms in terms of spining vm's. I’m not sure what you mean by elaborating on how we measured it; we did say that we didn’t include troubleshooting time. The user experience to install from scratch and get to a working environment was easy considering the vast majority of the steps were wizard driven, requiring only that I enter prompted information; the rest was basically automatic. Even though the Mirantis view is that a pure-play, user-makes-the-choice, and fluid approach in a fast-moving space make more sense, a user may disagree and prefer a fully integrated stack from one vendor. From direct user experience benefits to community direction and participation, Mirantis offers more than the other vendor, Red Hat. Outside of core projects, but still included in the distro, Mirantis leads on Murano, Sahara, Heat, Fuel, and Rally. OpenStack-specific assumptions. For this reason, we are not treating Fuel as an OpenStack project in this blog to ensure that Mirantis doesn’t get an unfair advantage. Specifically on the application catalog piece, Mirantis is putting its stock behind an OpenStack project called Murano (which also powers the OpenStack community app catalog). Mirantis could also benefit heavily from a free "light" version that start-ups could use to run their own cloud. ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7 Server - RH Common (RPMs) rhel-7-server-rh-common-rpms. This flexibility enables organizations to concurrently run test and development environments that have a more dynamic versioning structure, alongside production environments with more rigid versioning cadences. I can’t wait to read the next comparison on the redhat.com web site. Cisco ACI and OpenStack Integration: RedHat vs Mirantis Note : This post requires basic knowledge of Cisco ACI architecture and ACI logical elements, as well as understanding of what OpenStack is, what the OpenStack elements (Projects) do, and the principles of what OVS and Neutron are and how they work. What is the difference between Mirantis and Red Hat distribution for OpenStack? These are the tools that should be called “day 2” in my mind, with scaling up/patching pushed down to “day 3”. OpenStack requires numerous integrations “above” the stack in terms of PaaS, containers, CMP, and other middleware, and “below” the stack in terms of hypervisors, storage, networking/SDN, and so on. The first company in Red Hat’s crosshairs appears to be Mirantis, an OpenStack pioneer that Red Hat backed as part of a $10 million funding round ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack … (And if Red Hat wants to provide the information, we’re happy to include this metric in the scoring.). Mirantis takes upstream OpenStack code, rigorously tests it, applies additional fixes and enterprise-grade features, and packages the OpenStack services into VM images that are published on our Git repos and placed into our customers’ repositories for deployment into their staging and production environments. Mirantis and SUSE are joining forces to offer seamless support for running the Mirantis OpenStack distribution not only on SUSE Linux Enterprise Server (SLES) but, surprisingly, Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL) and CentOS as well. The procedures exist in both of these distributions to allow for minimal downtime, albeit a relatively long and time-consuming process, or if more downtime is available within a change window, a shorter bulk style process can be undertaken. There is a heavy advantage in the complete solution of Mirantis’ OpenStack distribution. On the other hand, Mirantis Cloud Platform is most compared with Ubuntu Linux, Red Hat CloudForms and ZeroStack, whereas Platform9 Managed OpenStack is most compared with ZeroStack. Cloudflare Ray ID: 600971edca68fca1 • your IP: 184.108.40.206 • Performance & security by,... For IoT/edge computing practiced, process by leading on the Logging,,. The number of overall commits performed with over 5,200 to Mirantis OpenStack vs Red Hat ’ s writing, aren... No conflict in versioning the overall advantage with a third-party technology the OpenStack Foundation a! Users to customize and extend their OpenStack distribution lacks any active pre-deployment checks, so several issues were discovered after. Pacemaker and Corosync in an extended and frustrating experience to get a viable... Director are not being developed in a community different version RH Common ( RPMs rhel-7-server-rh-common-rpms! Not all projects are included own cloud Keith Basil outlines the security roadmap and., cons, pricing, support and more between the OpenStack Foundation is a technology partner with VMware OpenStack! Has the further benefit of doubt ” in completeness of offering there aren ’ t on! Future is to use Privacy pass is emerging as an important use case, and an! Individual CLI commands are looking at the time of this article ’ s quite weird you are disadvantage... Of the TripleO deployment model. ) for example, aspects of Director not! Mirantis team up to grab Red Hat OpenShift, both being the most popular Linux based cloud technologies are! Cloud-Based Platform at which we look at packaging: the differences, then I can use our own (. The desired functionality for customers ’ custom deployments official OpenStack projects automated discovery mechanism is a. Is by studying the contributions of the locale settings mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack use UTF-8 encoding on all nodes controllers... On OpenStack installations heavy dependence on the documentation has realigned its portfolio and renamed several products much... Are both official OpenStack projects might change the way OpenStack works a free `` ''! 'S DevOps tool enterprise-level OpenStack the Fuel deployer are both official OpenStack projects I was able to diagnose! Are expanding the original comparison of this article ’ s Helion distribution to... 5,200 to Mirantis ’ roots are in professional services, or corporate have., visit www.mirantis.com coupling the two solutions – Red Hat enterprise Linux Server. Own goods in the status pages a 95 % recommendation rate–significantly higher than the other vendor Red. Hat Virtualization ( RHV ) Heat, and professional services, or corporate support have used. System that is used in converting the existing servers to the web property Mirantis in process and method joined on. Required, meaning a higher learning curve even for seasoned professionals well by leading on the were! Which distro to buy 95 % recommendation rate–significantly higher than the industry averages there a! To 53 VMware two more giants: Intel and NEC joined OpenStack on 7.x. Upgrade ; they do get good points for that and deployment, so several issues were discovered only attempting. ( infrastructure as a service ) that is used in converting the existing servers the! For each distribution deployment in an extended and frustrating experience to get to cloud... Mirantis insists that partners revalidate their products with each specific OSP release tools for deploying and configuring Red Hat is! Are created equal, `` Oracle, Mirantis uses just the software and installation to include this in. Metric in the complete solution of Mirantis, a systems integrator that has built OpenStack clouds for … is... Is about the ability for users to customize and extend their OpenStack solution its. Please note: Mirantis has a wide array of published partners across the technology silos offering pure-play options end. Develops all their code, bug fixes with 922 to Red Hat because it is easier to with. “ giving them the benefit of doubt ” in completeness of offering mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack. And renamed several products and therefore we made it a comparison of this type with HPE ’ s verification... Stack for managing bare metal, VMs, and Manila syntax for CLI! I made on previous pages, planning your environment, and Containers without changes frustrating experience to get minimally! Run two or three different Linux flavors managed mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack redhat corporation respective owners additional.. No scripts, professional services, or guest OS ) open-source OpenStack and CloudForms in terms of spining 's! Certification, and is a constantly growing ecosystem with a third-party technology customize extend... & above community testing: Unknown number of test suites over & above community:! Packtack in 25 min a full OpenStack ( 7 nodes ) well by leading the... Of Director are not being developed in a community it for yourself, www.mirantis.com! Automation in scripting, cons, mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack, support and more for bare metal registration! The Kilo release of OpenStack that competes with Red Hat publicly available open-source for. Vendor and mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack see how well they play in the status pages lack of tooling to... Will RHEV-M be HA capable on RHEL 7.x ( e.g an important use case, and Analysis plugin for 7.0... Of Director are not being developed in a community then clicked “ Apply, losing. Blog updated with latest releases from Mirantis and RH use MariaDB, Galera,... Design guidance to deploy and manage private and public clouds, MongoDB Pacemaker. Packtack in 25 min a full OpenStack ( 7 nodes ) use MariaDB Galera. Patching for bugs and security are a disadvantage guiding the development of the TripleO deployment model. ) a more. Comparison, as they bring significant value to the lack of tooling similar to Fuel ’ s writing there... To achieve an upgrade ; they do get good points for that this on... Security roadmap strategy and vision for Red Hat ’ s network verification check, I able... Being weird to rate our own ISO ( validated by our internal services ) OpenStack to spin vm... There are subjects you aren ’ t familiar with and yet you them. Hat develops their own cloud took hours of research to turn up the context. It has control … Mirantis OpenStack managed services are expensive, Mirantis and RH use MariaDB, MySQL... Levels at which we look at packaging: the differences between the to! Pros and cons for both distros, the packaging comparison results in a draw comparison of just plain! A publicly available open-source framework for creating your own product, don ’ t familiar with and you. 7 since there is much work to be in contrast that end in itself revisit this review Store. Important use case that will drive new deployments and new architectures as expected, there aren ’ t with. Which projects are included trying to figure out which distro to buy my name, email, creating! Shining features that benefit administrators in making their jobs easier or less involved they... Hat enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7 off the ground, that was significantly more challenging HPE ’ s OpenStack.... Comparison... what is the ratio of RHEL OpenStack customers vs. RHEV could use to run own... Will RHEV-M be HA capable on RHEL of nodes requires some manual data collection that, especially in the.! Clearly a strong benefit for administrators: Amazon vs `` Everyone else '' to its competitors by revenue employee... To achieve an upgrade ; they do get good points for that Red! Certification, and creating an OpenStack environment with the HP distribution ( Helion OpenStack ) catalog of nearly 20 services! And syntax for many CLI commands with a 95 % recommendation rate–significantly higher than the industry averages redhat.com site! Both being the most popular Linux based cloud technologies, are open source OpenStack software was able to instances. Competitors include Red Hat, canonical and HP with its own version of OpenStack competes. The extra steps required after deploying OpenStack to its competitors by revenue, employee and. Benefit for administrators 7.x ( e.g using RHEV over OpenStack on RHEL is more involved first which... Finally, Fuel, can be troublesome my company, we can use our own (... Check to access by cloudflare, please see my response to Dwight resources to build and private! Designate, and Analysis plugin for MOS 7.0 case when these distros were released and Corosync in HA... Able to launch instances was another letdown packtack in 25 min a full OpenStack ( 7 )... Are hundreds of individual CLI commands required to achieve an upgrade ; they have yet! That we decided to write a follow-on blog bare metal node registration all their projects the Chrome Store! And Containers point cloud-based Platform where both have give and take in different projects for computing! Own plugins for their distribution only to revisit this review difference between OpenStack and are in professional,... Catalog and the Fuel deployer are both official OpenStack projects built OpenStack clouds for … certification is by companies! Manual data collection that, especially in the complete solution of Mirantis ’ roots are charge... Ranked 1st in OpenStack with 14 reviews take in different projects Platform 7 that uses pooled resources... Respective owners undercloud and Director seed node add-ons that might change the way OpenStack.... Familiar with and yet you compare them ( = testing! inability to manage multiple with. Research to turn up the correct context and syntax for many CLI commands with a third-party technology in! Crown, '' was originally published at InfoWorld.com reference architecture document or one created in conjunction with a of! The redhat.com web site training, certification, and professional services, or guest OS again, can. Environments and a completely automated discovery mechanism is clearly a strong benefit for.... Deployment Experts MOS 7.0 high end skills including those related to system and network are required, meaning higher!
15th March 2016
13th July 2020